Vincenzo's Pastaria

Vicenzo's Pastaria has a cozy، conventional vibe—it’s not massive، but it’s definitely comfortable enough. The staff is friendly، but you can tell they’re swamped with orders، which makes the service feel a bit impersonal. However، the pizza is the absolute highlight; the crust and ingredients are top-tier and seriously delicious (you can even see the steam in the photo!). Even though the menu is a bit limited، what they do offer is honestly fantastic.

We eat here often. I have never taken the time to write a review. These are justa my thoughts which I hope will help Vincenzos and you. Tonight I had ... an Antipasto Salad، Eggplant، Mozzorella sticks، & garlic bread. The Antipasto salad was delicious as always. Some comments on the salad - best Antipasto salad in town especially as they are willing to let you substitute items or add items. It is twice the size of a huge sub piled high with meats، cheese، veggies& your add ons sitting on a crisp bed of lettuce! A variety of salad dressings.I love Mozzerella sticks but prefer mine more slender with less crumb coating. Just me. I ordered the garlic bread to eat with my eggplant (appetizer size). When I think of garlic bread I prefer a slice of Italian bread with buttered garlic topping. Vincenzo uses their sub bread sliced & with butter garlic. This is a bit too thick for me. Easy for them to just use one type bread (sub) for all bread items. Just my thoughts. We always phone in & pick up our order. They call us by name which is nice when you are a repeat customer. Never more than 20 minutes to pick up our dinner & living just around the corner means it is still nice & hot to eat. Thanks Vincenzo. Hope you take my comments in the Spirit they are given - always to help never hinder. And to those of you who may be newbies to the team or old timers looking for a nice little original Italian restaurant located in Islnd Park Road Plaza on Tamiami Trail. ENJOY! LaJuneMoore. 05/03/2026.

Raised in New York، I’ve teied a lot of places that say they have an authentic NY style pizza but Vincenzo’s is spot on. From the bubbles in the cheese، to the perfect crust you fold in half to eat (like a real New Yorker)، to the flavor which is just outstanding، Vincenzo’s nails it. Once you try their pizza you’ll be too spoiled to go anywhere else. The staff is always smiling and all are super friendly. The restaurant is very clean and inviting and always smells so good. Vincenzo’s is the hidden gem of the Island Park area. Definitely try a slice youll be hooked!

I am from New York and pleasantly surprised how amazing this pizza was and the calzone I ordered. Service was top notch! Skylar and the staff were great!. I will be going back.

Best Pizza in SWFL. This is real Brooklyn thin crust، NY style pizza. Nobody in town comes close. It’s like going home again to the old neighborhood and experiencing the best flavor in the world at the place you and your friends craved all week long. It hits so close to home they even have the old faux brick paneling my parents had in the basement. I haven’t tried the other menu items because I can’t wast a trip here without having pizza.